Without The Right Policies, Energy Storage Could Increase Emissions

on January 15, 2019 at 10:00 AM

In December, the six major Independent Systems Operators (ISO’s) across the country filed their plans for creating new market rules and opportunities for energy storage. While the rules will take at least a year to go into effect and the plans are just an initial step, a recent study suggests that this effort may add up to 50,000 megawatts (MW) of storage nationwide in the next decade.

At the same time, many states – like CaliforniaMassachusettsNew Jersey and New York – are recognizing the potential value of energy storage and are starting to integrate it as a key component of their plans to meet climate and renewable energy goals.

Combined with falling capital costs, these trends suggest a lot of new energy storage in the pipeline. This presents both opportunities and challenges for states looking to reduce their greenhouse gas emissions.

Not all energy storage is “clean”

When designed and incentivized properly, energy storage can be charged using clean power, and that power can then be discharged to displace dirtier power later in the day. While this is the optimal outcome, a growing body of research suggests that energy storage could actually increase emissions if it’s not done carefully.

Without the right policies, energy storage could increase emissionsCLICK TO TWEET

The environmental benefits of storage depend critically on how, and when, it is operated. Electricity rates, wholesale energy markets and the physical constraints of the electricity grid all combine to incentivize when storage owners charge and discharge their devices, and for what purpose – the “how” and “when” of storage utilization. Essentially, the effect that energy storage has on emissions depends on which power plants are used to charge the storage, which plants are offset when the storage discharges, and how efficiently the storage itself operates.

Strategies to address emissions from storage

Fortunately, there is a lot that can be done to proactively address these issues and ensure energy storage is supporting our clean energy goals, including:

  • Provide a greenhouse gas signal: Providing storage operators and regulators with a real-time and forecasted signal for greenhouse gas conditions can improve the emissions performance of storage. This signal has been effective at improving greenhouse gas performance in California’s incentive program (SGIP), but it can become even more powerful when tied to regulatory requirements for incentive programs or market participation.
  • Institute effective carbon pricing: An electric-sector carbon pricing program, such as the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative (RGGI) or NYISO’s carbon pricing proposal could help drive greenhouse gas reductions from storage by incentivizing charging from clean energy.
  • Focus state efforts on rate design and incentive programs:States can influence the performance of storage directly by requiring utilities to develop dynamic electricity rates that reflect grid conditions, which can incentivize storage to beneficially shift its operations. Further, states should incorporate emissions into procurement and planning processes that require energy storage to be supportive of greenhouse gas reductions and clean energy goals.
  • Develop market products that leverage renewable energy: At the wholesale market level, it is critical to design products that reward storage for its ability to integrate more renewables, reduce curtailment, and drive decarbonization. California is already exploring this approach through the ESDER III Load Shift Pilot.

Energy storage will play a critical role in our clean energy future. We are just starting to tap its potential benefits for customers, utilities, the grid and the environment. But these benefits won’t be realized automatically. Grid operators, state policymakers, utilities and other stakeholders must proactively create the right economic and market conditions to ensure energy storage drives decarbonization in the power sector.


Originally Published on January 10, 2018

The Energy Exchange Blog is a forum where EDF‘s energy experts discuss how to accelerate the transition to a clean, low-carbon energy economy. Follow them on Twitter here: @EDFEnergyEX